Tender for Fixing Rate contract for supply and installation of Motorized Vision Drum, Trial Lens Set with Trail
reference not parsedTNMSC
Particulars
de3f3462_CA119_2022.pdf
- Reference
- —
- Dated
- —
- Inviting authority
- General Manager (E)
- Bids invited
- 10.08.2021
- Opened
- 29.10.2021
- Bids declared
- 2
- On record
- 2 firms / 7 lines
- Schedules
- 5
- Procuring entity
- TNMSC
Pre-award integrity screen
3 medRe-run
Verify, don’t concludeevery flag has an innocent explanation too
- mediumBidders repeatedly appear togetherrepeat_cobidding
These two have bid in the same tender 2 times. 10% of their combined tender activity is spent facing each other.
Evidence- cb5e7204_CA118_2022.pdf
- de3f3462_CA119_2022.pdf
- mediumOne bidder takes most awards in this setwin_concentration
APPASAMY ASSOCIATES PVT LTD holds 25 of 32 recorded wins among these bidders (78%). Persistent losers who keep bidding may be providing cover.
Evidence- APPASAMY ASSOCIATES PVT LTD: 25 wins / 31 bids
- ALAN MEDICAL AND LABORATORY PRODUCTS: 7 wins / 16 bids
- mediumVery few biddersinsufficient_competition
Only 2 bidder(s) in this tender. Thin participation both weakens price discovery and makes an arrangement easier to sustain. Consider whether the specification or qualification criteria are narrowing the field.
Evidence- APPASAMY ASSOCIATES PVT LTD
- ALAN MEDICAL AND LABORATORY PRODUCTS
Bidders on record
2 firms
Schedule 1 Motorized Vision Drum – General Rate contract
| # | Bidder | Address | Price | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s. Appasamy Associates Pvt. Ltd | Chennai – 600 106. | Equipment: 18,480/- (Incl.GST @ 12%) CAMC: 500/- (4th to 10th year) (Excl.GST @ 18%) | Awarded |
| 2 | M/s. Alan Medical & Laboratory Products | Chennai - 600 002. | not published | Not selected |
Schedule 2 Trial Lens Set with Trail Frame – General Rate contract
| # | Bidder | Address | Price | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s. Alan Medical & Laboratory Products | Chennai - 600 002. | Equipment: 9,184/- (Incl.GST @ 12%) CAMC: 500/- (4th to 10th year) (Excl.GST @ 18%) | Awarded |
Schedule 3 Ultrasound Pachymeter – General Rate contract
| # | Bidder | Address | Price | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s. Appasamy Associates Pvt. Ltd | Chennai – 600 106. | Equipment: 3,36,000/- (Incl.GST @ 12%) CAMC: 5,000/- (4th to 10th year) (Excl.GST @ 18%) | Awarded |
Schedule 4 Keratometer Manual – General Rate contract
| # | Bidder | Address | Price | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s. Alan Medical & Laboratory Products | Chennai - 600 002. | Equipment: 49,840/- (Incl.GST @ 12%) CAMC: 2,000/- (4th year) 2,200/- (5th year) 2,400/- (6th year) 2,600/- (7th year) 2,800/- (8th year) | Awarded |
| 2 | M/s. Appasamy Associates Pvt. Ltd | Chennai – 600 106. | not published | Not selected |
Schedule 5 Synoptophore – General Rate contract
| # | Bidder | Address | Price | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M/s. Appasamy Associates Pvt. Ltd | Chennai – 600 106 | Equipment: 1,96,000/- (Incl.GST @ 12%) CAMC: 5,000/- (4th to 10th year) (Excl.GST @ 18%) | Awarded |
Blank price ≠ identical bid
These documents publish the awarded price per schedule, not what each bidder quoted, so the figure appears only against the winner. Price-clustering analysis needs the bid tabulation sheet, which is not published.