Online Tender for Fixing Rate Contract For supply of Oxygen Cylinder to various Govt. Institutions

reference not parsedTNMSC

Particulars

4099d55f_CA167_2023.pdf
Reference
Dated
Inviting authority
General Manager (E)
Bids invited
28.02.2023
Opened
27.03.2023
Bids declared
4
On record
4 firms / 16 lines
Schedules
4
Procuring entity
TNMSC

Pre-award integrity screen

2 medRe-run
Verify, don’t concludeevery flag has an innocent explanation too
  1. mediumBidders repeatedly appear togetherrepeat_cobidding

    These two have bid in the same tender 3 times. 25% of their combined tender activity is spent facing each other.

    Evidence
    • 4099d55f_CA167_2023.pdf
    • 7392b46a_CA116_2022.pdf
    • e921d66f_CA149_2023.pdf
  2. mediumBidder never wins but keeps biddingperennial_loser

    1 bidder(s) here have bid repeatedly without a single recorded win. That is consistent with cover bidding, and also with a genuinely uncompetitive supplier — check quoted prices.

    Evidence
    • SAFE PRO FIRE SERVICES PVT LTD: 0 wins in 4 bids

Bidders on record

4 firms

Schedule 1a Oxygen Cylinder B Type with Flow meter with Oxygen Cylinder Stand with MS Type – 494 nos.

#BidderAddressPriceOutcome
1M/s. Madras Surgicals & ChemicalsM/s. Thirupathi Enterprises 6,330/- Make: M/s.Rama Cylinder M/s. Solokrafts Industries Make : M/s.Everest 6,800/- Kanto Cylinder Limited M/s. Madras Surgicals &Awarded
2M/s. Safe Pro Fire Services Pvt. Ltdnot publishedNot selected
3M/s. Solokrafts Industriesnot publishedNot selected
4M/s. Thirupathi Enterprisesnot publishedNot selected

Schedule 1b Oxygen Cylinder B Type with Flow meter with Oxygen Cylinder Stand with SS Type – 494 nos.

#BidderAddressPriceOutcome
1M/s. Madras Surgicals & ChemicalsM/s. Thirupathi Enterprises 6,630/- Make: M/s.Rama CylinderAwarded
2M/s. Safe Pro Fire Services Pvt. Ltdnot publishedNot selected
3M/s. Solokrafts Industriesnot publishedAwarded
4M/s. Thirupathi Enterprisesnot publishedNot selected

Schedule 2a Oxygen Cylinder D Type (Including Hose) Trolley with MS Type – 208 nos.

#BidderAddressPriceOutcome
1M/s. Madras Surgicals & ChemicalsM/s. Thirupathi Enterprises 14,592/- Make: M/s.Rama Cylinder M/s. Solokrafts Industries Make : M/s.Everest 16,340/- Kanto Cylinder Limited M/s. Madras SurgicalsAwarded
2M/s. Safe Pro Fire Services Pvt. Ltdnot publishedNot selected
3M/s. Solokrafts Industriesnot publishedNot selected
4M/s. Thirupathi Enterprisesnot publishedNot selected

Schedule 2b Oxygen Cylinder D Type (Including Hose) Trolley with SS Type – 208 nos.

#BidderAddressPriceOutcome
1M/s. Madras Surgicals & ChemicalsM/s. Thirupathi Enterprises 14,992/- Make: M/s.Rama Cylinder M/s. Solokrafts Industries Make : M/s.Everest 17,150/- Kanto Cylinder Limited M/s. Madras SurgicalsAwarded
2M/s. Safe Pro Fire Services Pvt. Ltdnot publishedNot selected
3M/s. Solokrafts Industriesnot publishedNot selected
4M/s. Thirupathi Enterprisesnot publishedNot selected

Blank price ≠ identical bid

These documents publish the awarded price per schedule, not what each bidder quoted, so the figure appears only against the winner. Price-clustering analysis needs the bid tabulation sheet, which is not published.